Too Good To Be True by Prajakta Koli – India’s Most Talked-About Novel of 2025

When a Book Becomes a Cultural Wave

Every year, a few novels rise above the crowd and create conversations that spill far beyond bookstores. In 2025, one debut novel has captured that spotlight: Too Good To Be True by Prajakta Koli.

In just one month of release, the book sold over 1,50,000 copies, making it one of the fastest-selling Indian novels of the decade. It didn’t stop there—the novel quickly won the Amazon India Popular Choice Debut Book 2025 Award, cementing its place as a bestseller. It is written by Prajakta Koli .

But numbers alone don’t explain the craze. The real reason this novel is being called India’s most talked-about book of 2025 lies in its heart: a deeply relatable story about love, loss, and navigating modern life in a world full of contradictions.

Who Is Prajakta Koli? From YouTube Star to Bestselling Author

Before becoming a published author, Prajakta Koli was already a household name in India. Known as “MostlySane”, she is one of the country’s most beloved YouTubers, with millions of subscribers and followers across platforms.

But stepping into the world of publishing was different. For Prajakta, Too Good To Be True wasn’t about chasing trends—it was about telling a story that feels both personal and universal. And that’s exactly what struck readers.

Her transition from a digital creator to a bestselling novelist shows how storytelling transcends platforms. Whether through videos or books, Prajakta knows how to connect with human emotions in a way that feels authentic.

What Makes Too Good To Be True Stand Out?

Unlike many debut novels that take time to build traction, this book exploded immediately. But why?

1. Relatable Themes

At its core, the novel talks about friendship, heartbreak, family, ambition, and self-discovery—themes every young Indian can connect with. And the author is also so relatable and famous.

2. Modern Storytelling Style

The language is simple yet powerful, weaving together emotions without being heavy-handed. It feels like a friend telling you a story over coffee—honest, raw, and engaging.

3. Cultural Relevance

In an age where readers crave stories that reflect their own experiences, Prajakta delivers exactly that. The novel mirrors contemporary Indian youth culture, exploring issues like digital life, relationships in the 21st century, and the pressure to “have it all.”

Breaking Records in Indian Publishing

The novel’s immediate success shocked even the publishing world. Selling 1,50,000 copies in one month is not just rare—it’s almost unheard of for a debut novel.

This success indicates a shift in reading culture among young Indians:

They’re looking for relatable voices rather than purely literary ones.
They want fast-paced, emotional stories that reflect their own struggles.
They resonate with authors who have already been a part of their daily lives (like Prajakta through YouTube).

A Deeper Look at the Story

While avoiding spoilers, the plot of Too Good To Be True revolves around characters navigating the complexities of relationships, trust, and self-worth.

The narrative explores:

The fragility of human connections.
The clash between personal desires and societal expectations.
The search for meaning in a chaotic world.

Instead of presenting a fairy-tale romance or a picture-perfect life, Prajakta focuses on the messiness of being human—the doubts, the heartbreaks, and the moments of vulnerability, the chaos .

Why Readers Are Obsessed With It

1. It Speaks Their Language

Prajakta writes the way her audience talks. There’s no pretension, no over-complication—just a genuine flow that makes you feel at home.

2. It Feels Personal

Many readers have said they felt like the book was “written for them.” That’s because the struggles and questions raised in the novel mirror what millions of young Indians face daily.

3. It’s Honest About Modern Love

Instead of glamorizing love, the book shows both its beauty and its pain. This honesty makes it resonate on a deeper level.

Comparison with Other Contemporary Indian Novels

While books like It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover (international) and The Girl in Room 105 by Chetan Bhagat (Indian) created waves in their time, Prajakta’s Too Good To Be True is different.

Where Bhagat often uses humor and thrill, Prajakta uses authentic emotions. Where Hoover portrays love with dramatic intensity, Prajakta offers a story that feels rooted in real Indian experiences.

This unique blend of relatability and rawness makes it stand out among current bestsellers.

Reader Reactions: Voices From Across India

Social media has been flooded with reactions:

“This book made me cry, smile, and reflect on my own life.”
“I didn’t expect a debut novel to hit this hard.”
“It felt like Prajakta was telling my own story.”

Book clubs, college campuses, and even online forums are buzzing with discussions. It’s not just being read—it’s being felt.

Why You Should Read Too Good To Be True

Because it’s the most talked-about Indian novel of 2025.
Because it will make you reflect on your own relationships.
Because it blends entertainment and emotional depth beautifully.
Because it represents the voice of modern Indian youth.

5 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1. Who is the author of Too Good To Be True?
Prajakta Koli, popularly known as “MostlySane,” a YouTuber and digital creator, is the author.

Q2. Why is this book so popular?
Its relatable themes, emotional depth, and conversational style have made it a bestseller in India.

Q3. How many copies has it sold?
Over 1,50,000 copies within the first month of release.

Q4. What kind of readers will enjoy it?
Anyone who enjoys stories of love, friendship, and self-discovery will connect deeply with this novel.

Q5. Is it worth reading if I don’t usually read romance or contemporary fiction?
Yes! The novel goes beyond romance—it’s about life, struggles, and the search for meaning, which makes it universal.

Conclusion: More Than Just a Novel

Too Good To Be True isn’t just a book—it’s an emotional journey. It has proven that when an author writes with honesty and heart, readers respond with love and loyalty. That's why its become one of the most talked about books.

In a publishing industry often dominated by formulaic stories, Prajakta Koli’s debut has broken barriers. It’s not only India’s most talked-about novel of 2025 but also a sign of how storytelling is evolving for the new generation.

If you’re looking for a book that will make you laugh, cry, and think about your own life, this is the one you cannot miss.

The Palace of Illusions by Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni: A Feminist Retelling of the Mahabharata

What if the Mahabharata was told from Draupadi’s perspective? The Palace of Illusions by Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni is a bold and fascinating retelling of the epic, giving voice to one of the most powerful yet misunderstood women in mythology. This bestselling novel takes us into Draupadi’s inner world—from her birth in fire to her marriage to five husbands, her secret love for Karna, and the events that lead to the devastating war of Kurukshetra. It’s a story of love, ambition, destiny, and the illusions we live by , told in poetic language that stays with you long after the last page. Themes of feminism, identity, forbidden love, and fate vs free will make this book timeless and highly relevant in 2025. Draupadi is portrayed as strong, unapologetic, and deeply human—a woman who refuses to be defined by tradition. Some of its most unforgettable lines include: “A problem becomes a problem only if you believe it to be so.” “Illusion is sometimes all that keeps us going.” “A woman w...

The Reading Nook

Search This Blog